https://www.biggerpockets.com/rei/real-estate-comps-house-va...
Yet again the tech community believing a problem exists to be solved that has already been solved.
> In most markets comparables are acquired through an MLS database, and access to MLS is usually not free.
This is true; you need to pay for access to the data source (no different than having to pay for access to equities market data). Redfin succeeds at this because they're a brokerage that happens to be a tech company, unlike Zillow who tries to just pay for feeds (that usually have stale data).
You can hire or become friends with a real estate professional that pays for access to MLS (or become one yourself).
But before sites like Zillow, there wasn't anything like it easily available to the average person.
Zillow unfortunately doesn't help though, as no one takes the value seriously (except perhaps uneducated consumers entering the real estate market). Bad data is worse than no data.
Some properties are only on the market for hours/days; you'd never have a chance as a market participant if you only relied on stale public records.
I don't think appraisers can use MLS listings exclusively when valuing a property. The primary source is typically public records data.