(Traditional) REITs are priced more or less like a bond by the markets and will be largely evaluated based on their yield. As a result, you're missing out on the appreciation component of real estate. You also don't get the tax benefits of the interest deduction. With a direct investment, you can look at things like which areas will disproportionately appreciate in the future. It's more like an active investment in a value stock with a nice dividend to boot.
As for a REIT over direct property, REIT's are not bad but they don't compare to direct investments and as @aliston point out you miss out on appreciation. Overall from what I have seen a decent REIT might get you 10-13% annually, which isn't bad. However, it is quite a different type of investment that is also subject to the stock market turns, interest rate changes and other financial market forces which have negative changes more often then does the raw property investment. Hence, unless you have substantial amount to invest, getting much out of a REIT will take a while.
As for rentals, they are not a get rich quick scheme, but over relatively short times they make you comfortable and give you security in passive income. Over the longer term the property values along with some rehab projects can make you "rich" and then if you keep at it, mixing in some commercial property is always good, you have the possibility of becoming wealthy.