I find that having a branch name that was the sole branch name when the code was made gives context to the commit; why it was made and what its purpose was. Being reachable from a branch pointer doesn't give that same context. Yes, commit messages should handle this. But I find they don't.
> It's useless at best and misleading at worst.
This has not been my experience. I haven't found a great need for "what's the whole state a year ago"; more so "what was the context around this commit", which I think a mercurial-style branch name answers.