If he were to publicly announce it as a major issue, he'd have looked partisan. Instead he tried to walk the middle ground by announcing it publicly and downplaying its significance. It was a challenging situation and it seems a fairly reasonable response to me. About as principled as he could be given the situation at hand.
Comey's priorities must be far greater than personal fallout: He is responsible for things so important we don't even question them (or don't want to): The law, justice, one of the most important institutions in the U.S. (the FBI), and in this case, arguably the most important institution in the world, the sanctity of U.S. democracy.
I don't care if he was in a bind; that is not a concern at all with these stakes; he shouldn't have the job if he can't handle these situations.
It may appear to civilians as if it is a bind, but my understanding based on what a large number of former top officials said is that the FBI and Justice Department have two unambiguous, long-standing policies on these issues: 1) Never talk about ongoing investigations, and 2) never say anything that will influence an election in any way.
You don't want the head of the FBI making decisions every four years (or 2 - they could influence every House and Senate race) on what election-related information they will reveal. Finally, did Comey reveal every investigation that might have influenced the election? No, only one. What about the one into Russian interference, for example? The only violation of those policies, ever AFAIK, was what Comey did.
Imagine Congress calls you in to testify under oath about something, over and over. This is not a big priority for you, but it is something the oversight committees care about a lot and cooperation can make your life easier when it comes to e.g. getting funding for solving serial killings.
They make you testify under oath over and over about e.g. the number of emails. They ask you on Monday under penalty of perjury, and by Wednesday you have a new answer.
Your choices are to tell them, have it leak, and be criticized for influencing an election. Or don't tell them, make your life harder, and have them say you were concealing relevant information before the election (because we all found out it was nothing in advance of the election, so the concealing would have broken as a news story too).
Honestly, he was going to get tagged with this either way. It was just which flavor of scandal he wanted.
His incompetence/misdirection on technical matters could lead us down a very dark path. It leaves me little patience for anything else from him, as either he's too dated to function in a modern era and too proud to delegate, or he's busy selling out everyone.
(If you think reasonable people can't disagree about it, you're probably misconstruing the debate. You know this is happening if, for instance, the next rhetorical move you have to make is about how it's impossible to "ban mathematics" or about how "only outlaws will have cryptography".)
I am very unlikely to hold a bias against encryption against someone like James Comey. And I work in cryptography! I disagree with him about it, but that doesn't make him a bad person.
On the other hand, I have a hard time working around him violating what is apparently a very real election norm of the institution he runs. That to me suggests that he's unprincipled, which is the kind of thing I really have a problem with.
Whether this theory seems correct, and whether it argues for principled or unprincipled, I suspect will have varying answers depending on who you ask.
He said the agency was pursuing terrorists and he thought the locked iphone was important, but he specifically didn't actually take it to anyone who could help, indicating that he was 1) lying or 2) willing to let more attacks happen to make a point.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_Three_of_the_United_St...
"Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort."