My underlying question would be: Are they a symptom of a systemic flaw (basically a parasite) or does their role in the financial ecosystem somehow justify that kind of profits?
My underlying question would be: Are they a symptom of a systemic flaw (basically a parasite) or does their role in the financial ecosystem somehow justify that kind of profits?
They are 'market makers'. If you're a big {pension, real estate, rrsp}fund and want to make a trade, say a purchase, you need to call your trader directly. The trader will sell you some of their own (if they have it on their books), or will contact other people who they think may have extra supply on your behalf.
They are the 'grease of the economy'. In theory, it makes markets run smoother, which leads to greater efficiencies for everyone, and makes the world a better place.
(in theory)
On that theme - would you say that it is more noble to be a mechanic than programmer, and more noble to be a farmer than a mechanic?