It is true that "blockchain" is increasingly a literally meaningless marketing buzzword (e.g. R3 Corda, a "blockchain" product that brags of not actually containing a blockchain). However, this doesn't really help convince.
It is true that "blockchain" is increasingly a literally meaningless marketing buzzword (e.g. R3 Corda, a "blockchain" product that brags of not actually containing a blockchain). However, this doesn't really help convince.
To me, it still has enough information content to be useful. Just because different people have different definitions doesn't mean the information content is zero. People may agree on the broad ideas and disagree about the specifics. And as discussed in another comment, definitions are nonetheless useful to help summarize a set of properties, help communication, and more.
For example, I think most people would agree a blockchain needs to have the property of having a consensus mechanism. Versus say a file system which typically doesn't.
And that's ok! It's designed for different problems, like file system style blob storage. It's not about "whether something is a blockchain", it's about "what's the right tool for the job"? I see value in complementary decentralized pieces of file systems, databases, processing, and more.
> It's not about "whether something is a blockchain"
It arguably is when you call your post "Blockchains for Artificial Intelligence".
For this context it's really about whether or not it can prevent double spends. Currently, it can't. Though its protocol stack has a place for consensus algorithms to achieve CAP-style strong consistency; and the IPFS team is working on consistency algorithms.
> It arguably is when ...
Point taken. The post is about things that many people consider to be blockchains or at least blockchain-like; BigchainDB, Ethereum, and others are in that category.