A team of 40 cannot create anything that competes with the android of today. Not even Andy can do that.
A team of 40 cannot create anything that competes with the android of today. Not even Andy can do that.
Especially if the alternative means making substantial modifications to Android.
Alternatively, one could build a dual stack Android, with one compatible UI stack and one built for the edge to edge UX.
Granted, the article seems to focus on AI mixins, but "it runs 90% of the top 1000 apps, and all of the most popular ones, with 30% better battery life" could be compelling too.
I know very little about Android, but I thought your comment has some merit.
I agree those things are all important considerations but you're lumping too many things together.
Some of those are antithetical. For example, buying into an existing app ecosystem means you don't get your own developer mindshare.
And tooling doesn't suffer from network effects the same way app stores and developers do. For example, they could use Android but write a new UI framework. They'd still make use of Android tooling, get partial entrée into the Android developer mindshare, but divest of the app base.
Personally I don't think a phone startup can succeed without creating a new UI framework around a new paradigm, whether it's VR, social, AI, semantic Web, or whatever. Facebook had the right idea although they failed.
If you are just competing for the same users with the same apps you will lose to Samsung. You need a new app base. Imagine a game console that only had multiplatform games. Who would buy it? A game platform with no third party games but a few compelling (to a niche) first party ones would have a better foundation.
Obviously it takes 1000s to scale, and optimize, and automate every last thing. But to build the first 1? Team of 40.
i don't know. maybe they'll get it right this time...
Phone, sms, camera, email and web browsing are the essentials.
Everything else, FB, Instagram, Reddit etc that are usually done in apps on Android, they can be done with a decent browser.
And in many cases, you could potentially pass that stuff off to the cloud. Heck, voice recognition, AI and Hootsuite.
"Clara, show me that photo in monochrome."
"Here you go Nexxxeh, I've applied a filter called 'HDR Noir Pop'. Would you like to see other filters for monochrome? "
"Post this to Insta, caption 'Phone mirror selfie hashtag Essential hashtag swag'. Then link that on Twitter, caption 'hashtag essential'."
"Immediately or schedule for your usual time of 7pm?"
"Schedule."
"That's been scheduled for 7pm, alongside publishing the YouTube video entitled 'Essential Phone Unboxing' on your main YouTube channel and a link published to Facebook.
Your flight for 6pm is still on time, your Uber is booked for 5pm and the estimated journey time is 30 minutes. Your packing checklist is complete.
Would you like to watch today's Philip DeFranco show on YouTube?"
That's all stuff Alexa /could/ do if she was made a bit more proactive.
Arguably the hard problems have been solved elsewhere. You've just got to pay for them and integrate.
I don't think it's inconceivable.
I think the point the OP is making is that any custom OS will, at this point, fail. Windows Phone, WebOS and FirefoxOS all tried and couldn't compete with the sheer number of apps on other platforms. You say that a decent browser will be a fine substitute for apps, I'd argue that every OS that has tried to do this and failed is evidence that it is not an acceptable substitute at all.
Some days I still wonder what the world would look like if geeks had picked WebOS instead of Android to rally around.
And while we're in the topic of AI assistants, I still think these voice-only interfaces on iOS/Android, don't match the simplicity of webOS' Just Type. You have to memorize the capabilities and/or syntax for Siri and Google Assistant whereas webOS would autocomplete/autosuggest as you 'Just Type'. That experience is still profound imo. (If any of Andy Rubin's Essential team is reading this, please add 'Just Type' as a core feature to your assistant)
[1] http://ignorethecode.net/blog/2012/02/21/steal_webos_feature...