Whether 13 weeks of paid parental leave or this healthcare plan vs that one or this change to the telecommuting rules that they advocated for is irrelevant. Did the company succeed and thrive and serve its stakeholders?
One measure that I've seen recently (and like) is "compounded growth rate, over 6-10 years, of the 3 year moving average of stock price" from grant to payout date, subject to minimum thresholds [so you're not just paying for ordinary market growth].
That measure is also imperfect, but it seems less imperfect than others. (Disclosure: the company I work for adopted such a plan last year, so we won't know how it really plays out for at least 5.5 more years. Edit: program summary here: http://ir.cimpress.com/mobile.view?c=188894&v=202&d=3&id=aHR... )