Are you saying that because only doctors would be able to give ratings, those ratings would be more credible? I agree that __should__ be the case, but it wouldn't/isn't (http://jnci.oxfordjournals.org/content/99/15/1148.full). I cannot find the source, but I once read that there was a very small minority of doctors in the country subscribing the most brand-name drugs simply because of perks offered by drug companies.