http://personal.lse.ac.uk/robert49/teaching/methodologies/pd...
http://personal.lse.ac.uk/robert49/teaching/methodologies/pd...
I find it fairly hilarious since at it looks like the standard Divide by Zero algebra problem, but then error after error compounds the result.
The first error appears to be in an un-numbered equation:
sin(theta)=dh/dr which is equal to 0 at r=0!!
which is then substituted into the differential equation:
F=g dh/dr = sqrt(r) = d^2r/dt^2 again equal to ZERO at r=0
Of course this is also an abuse of Leibniz notation (mathematicians squirm whenever physicists do this sort of "algebra" on differentials) which is then integrated twice and then differentiated twice (ignoring constants of integration) to get the equations for r(t) and a(t).
The second key is the square root, which allows for multiple solutions of the differential equation (one of which is the normal r=a=0), but that's just part of the side show. Physics has all sorts of "non-physical" results from integrations, DiffEq, etc. A classic being a negative time solution to parabolic trajectories.
I would add the use the statistics of continuos probability distributions to say that there is in fact ZERO probability that any ball is at r=0 just to complete the silliness. Perhaps he's willing to co-author a follow up?
Of course, Newton doesn't let me prove it's the table. It could be, for example, an apple-suspending demon which only acts in the presence of tables (and other solid objects). Newton does not allow me to eliminate that possibility (but Occam does).
Well, in a way it does, as long as these forces are "conservative", which includes gravitational field that you mentioned as well as (static) electric field.
On the other hand, you are correct, it is not a goal of classical mechanics as a mathematical theory to describe any specific physical force in particular. In that sense it can be seen as "incomplete" - as a physical theory. But classical mechanics as a (modern) physical theory is not only "incomplete", it is also plain "wrong"! (But that is a topic for another time, perhaps.)