Hacker News Reader

Comment by DanieIGackIe | Hacker News Reader

Please don't do this here.

Do what? Post articles from Nature?

This isn't original research by @based2, it's primary research, authored and reviewed by credentialed scientists. And even if it was, this isn't Wikipedia - HN is a great place for primary sources.

I would much rather read this (or even just skim the abstract and conclusions) than some so-called "scientific journalism" that typically distorts, exaggerates, and confuses the issues.

Right. Nature is about as credible a source as you can get.

Note that this paper is from Nature: Scientific Reports, which is also published by Nature Publishing Group, but is not the Nature journal you're thinking of. SRep is not in the same tier as Nature.

Thanks for pointing that out.

I'm guessing that it's still a long way removed from "spam", though, right? :-)

Well, SR did have a bit of a credibility issue when they started, and even today, it's not exactly a top journal. I understand it's not a criterion that the articles published are groundbreaking or similar, just that they're decent science and that the authors are willing to pay the hefty fee.

Edit:

See here for one particular discussion, from last year

http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2016/06/15/mor...

I'm not sure I understand the problem. From my perspective (maybe wrong), the OP tracked down the Nature blurb and posted it. Maybe for authority, maybe because HN focuses on English language discussion.

Presumably, the OP first ran across the news in Le Monde. Well, ok; while I appreciate actually having a somewhat de facto lingua, um, franca for conversation on HN, I can cope with citations to content in other languages. Particularly when the OP is considerate enough to also provide an English language alternative.

While I'm about out the door, in a hurry, it also appears at a glance that the article in Le Monde may have more general background on the topic and its history of concerns.

Ignore that troll account.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com