"The Golden Rule (treat others as you would wish to be treated) has the same fatal flaw as future-is-like-the-past inductivism: it justifies anything and nothing, depending on what attributes of the other person you choose to imagine yourself having. And so, like induction, it only seems to yield some specific moral conclusion if you had already reached that conclusion by other means." - David Deutsch.
Here, "other means" is just the scientific method (conjecture, criticism) generalised to morality. So I'd say that the scientific method, (and a good epistemology in general), is a more valuable concept than the Golden Rule.
https://twitter.com/DavidDeutschOxf/status/25231910520029593...
This is particularly problematic because it assumes you know everything about the other person's situation.
"If I were acting like that, I would be thankful if someone hit me in the face to make me realize how rude I was being."
"If I were poor, I would be grateful for someone who took away my government handouts so I became self-sustaining."
"If I were rich, I wouldn't mind being taxed at 98%."
Etc
And just like there are people out there who disagree on what the golden rule means, so too are there people who disagree on the scientific method - I've lost count of the number of times that I've had to say here on HN that the scientific method extends beyond 'test the null hypothesis'.
> it justifies anything and nothing, depending on what attributes of the other person you choose to imagine yourself having.
Only if you apply it in a flawed or superficial manner. Heuving's example of "I'd like someone to punch me in the face" is a clear example of this. The scientific method has equally poor results if you apply it in a flawed or superficial manner.
In any case, regardless of opinion on which is better, they're both far more important to us as humans than atomic theory :)
"My songs are of time and distance. The sadness is in you."
https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/879764-count-zero
If the problem domain isn't amenable to the crude reductionism puny human brains are capable of, then there are other ways of "dealing with it." (Other than applying a hydraulic press.) Science can help you be a good dog owner, but not all of the problem solving strategies and wisdom most dog owners will be the scientific method. The same goes for being a human being.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rechtsstaat
(Until now I didn't even know that this German word is also used in the English language.)
The "state of law" is a combination of the Golden rule (which works only within small groups) with some aspects of the scientific method (reproducible results and independence of the subject: If I do the same thing as somebody else, in the same circumstances, it should be equally okay. Or, if it is not okay, we both should face the same consequences).