You should refrain from talking about things you clearly know nothing about.
You should refrain from talking about things you clearly know nothing about.
It will be an interesting case for certain but people outside the US can't sue the US government demanding entry. They have no standing.
As a citizen, I barely have legal standing to sue for a denial of passport.
The affected people already present might have some standing to fight their denial of entry as they are here legally but people here illegally have no such right.
The biggest effect of this order is people here legally and those who previously had legal access to the US. There are a ton of people with legal grounding here, and this case holds significant precedent for them.
People granted a Green Card are here illegally?
Nice to see you already walking back your incorrect claims though. Perhaps in the future you will refrain from making blanket and false assertions on the law.
Thse citizens of those countries have ZERO, none, less than zero standing to sue in US federal court. Any less clear?
The only people who might have standing are those already in US airports with proper visas who are being denied entry because they can show imminent harm and that is their only standing.
Boumedine v Bush is about haebaus corpus and unlawful imprisonment and has absolutely nothing to do with the executive order under discussion.
This is clearly wrong. Dual citizens, for example.
Can you please clarify your legal qualifications? Or at least provide some references to back up the claims you're making?
The order is about denying visas to foreign nationals and denying status to some refugees and directing the various departments to submit plans, etc on a timeline.
The only reference required to back up this claim is the text of the order itself? The NYTimes has the full text for you to read at https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/27/us/politics/refugee-musli...
Alien Tort Statute establishes (among other things) that non-citizens can seek remedy in US courts for civil actions to remedy violations of treaty obligations or international law in the absence of any more proper legal forum.
There is no treaty obligation to allow entry into the US from the countries listed in the executive order.
[1] https://www.aclu.org/legal-document/darweesh-v-trump-petitio...
Here is an excerpt:
nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws
Even people here illegally might have some standing in court (under international and amnesty laws). You clearly have no idea what you're talking about.
https://www.cbp.gov/travel/international-visitors/visa-waive...
Do you think magically that no one was previously denied entry and faced irreparable harm based on this longstanding policy of the previous administration and passed into law by Congress?
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1187
You will have to state specifically which "international and amnesty laws" you think the US has been violating for the past several years if you wish for me to comment.