Ive always struggled to understand Sartre's popularity even among other philosophers I respect.
Ive always struggled to understand Sartre's popularity even among other philosophers I respect.
I agree completely.
It is completely rankling when considering how he is compared to Simone de Beauvoir. Her "Second Sex" is considered a feminist work—and for good reason—but it surpasses any of what Sarte wrote as a philosophical work. While he did build on the backs of others, his ideas remain small compared to his contemporaries.
Merleau-Ponty was definitely more connected to actual lived reality than Sartre was. When Marxist theory produced a horror, not paradise, he actually sort of admitted it was happening.
Being and Nothingness, as far as I understand, was a response in part to Heidegger's Being and Time.
My philosophy may be rusty, but to answer the question you asked, I think history is the reason why others held him in regard.