And medical history can't really be used to indict someone. Where this clearly was.
EDIT: can't be used to indict, only as addition evidence for a trial. It's an important distinction, but I'm not sure I think it's okay either.
In this case, it's very similar to saying. "If you don't let us install this device that the government can use to know exactly what you were doing every hour of every day; you'll die."
It's not quite the fact that it's medical history, but it's very detailed, personal medical history. "He had gout some time in the last few weeks/months" vs "He was running 14 times in the last 21 days, and heres' the exact minute he started and ended"
> but their medical history showed they actually required frequent treatment at a local hospital? Should that be inadmissible?
That they acquired treatment? Maybe. That they were treated for an STI? Yes, that should be inadmissible. Because as a medical person, I don't want you avoiding ANY treatment because you scared the information about the treatment would be used against you.
The 4th amendment isn't there to make it hard to get a conviction. It is there to make sure you aren't harassed by searches.
Where in this case, the got a court order to take information from a device. Not to compare it to a sample they already had, but at a single point of evidence, that will be used to incriminate.
Additionally, that same evidence could be used to prove innocence, where the pacemaker data couldn't be used as evidence to prove innocence.
EDIT, Also, the 4th is protection from unreasonable searches... e.g. if the device I required to live needs extra data to do it's job. IMO, it is an unreasonable search to use that against me because I have no choice in wither or not, I create the data, or use the device. Because the alternative is I choose to die.
Suppose there was a criminal who claimed that, with a broken leg, they couldn't possibly have committed some act. Isn't it reasonable to get a warrant for the person's XRays in order to get hard evidence that the person was or was not incapacitated?
The scary part to me is the medical examiner. They are making a very advanced claim (that they can determine something definitive about what the person was or was not doing) based on the heart data. Given previous overreaches from forensic examiners, I'd want to see some actual research before chucking the person into jail.
The more information about you that is available the more likely it is that a spurious correlation, misremembered facts or inferenced made from the data will often make you seem less trustworthy than somebody you have less data about as long as both parties behave according to societal norms.
If you have an actual impairment, especially cognitive, the situation is even worse.
Your pacemaker gathers that data (exertion history over time) so that your doctor can view it after the fact and ask you "what were you doing last Thursday afternoon? The pacemaker says it was running extra high between 3:30 and 4:30."
I think most people would opt into such a device for their own health - in fact, many might wear it on their wrist and pair it with their phone.