As an investor, my livelihood depends on my ability to consistently make sound decisions. And fortunately, decisions are not set in stone, so I have opportunities to negate poor ones.
I have thought a lot about how to improve my decision-making. One is what you are talking about, sharing my decisions and thought processes with others. An obvious conclusion (to me) is that doing so on the internet is horrible, as there is no real ability to filter opinions on my part, with no background knowledge of those giving feedback. Yet they can still sow seeds of self-doubt.
But even talking with friends can be tricky, as you have to account for their backgrounds and biases. Sometimes it's easy. For example, if I'm looking at real estate, something I know little about, I would heavily count the thoughts of my friend who is a REIT analyst. Other times it is not clear how much to weight their opinion. A Bayesian approach seems to work here.
Another idea which I find as effective, if not more, is constantly turning the decision over in my own mind. I am not the same person I was yesterday. My thought processes in the morning, after a cup of coffee, are different than Friday evening, after a few beers. It is definitely different after a period where the market is up ("I'm an invincible genius!") vs. down ("I'm a moron! Maybe I should go back to writing code...") By revisiting over a span of time, you can gather new insights solely based on where your head is at any given time.
And at the end of the day, you have to honestly evaluate the results of your decisions. If I discount the opinions of others and follow my own intuition, but consistently lose money, then well, I should revisit some part of the process. Surprisingly many are unable (unwilling?) to do this.