My experience tells me that the best developers are: - generous with their time to other devs
- not defensive about their code
- able to solve complex problems fast, and explain those solutions to other people
- able to focus really intensely
- enthusiastic about learning new things
- lazy about boring stuff (to the extent that they will spend 4 hours looking for a shortcut that saves them doing 1 hour of boring stuff)
but some of the most productive programmers I've worked with treated the entire thing as a job that they did from 9 to 5 to pay the bills, and their real interest lay elsewhere
and some of the best programmers I've seen were the hardest to manage, and ultimately were a net negative to the team
Coding is creative - there are an infinite number of ways to solve any given problem. This is why it's so hard to predict and manage, and resists quantification.
<edit for formatting>