Pros for this position:
1. The individual is incurring some level of risk by not vaccinating.
2. Society is incurring some level of risk if the individual's risk of getting the disease is increased (although shouldn't this not affect people who are vaccinated anyway?)
Cons:
1. You are mandating a person subject themselves to a medical procedure, a very personal violation of that person's liberty.
2. Taking a forced vaccine incurs its own (low) risk. A distant family member of mine contracted Polio from a Polio vaccine. The 'anti-vaxxers' have claims of other unhealthy complications of vaccines, some of which are probably true to a degree.
The only argument I see for mandatory vaccination is that it has to be done before the individual in question can legally consent, so perhaps 'society' should have greater say than the individual's parents for what's best for their child, similar to how society imposes certain education requirements, even for home schooling.