Encrypt. EVERYTHING. It's the power we do have, and it might be the only power.
If my ISP wants to pay me in the form of a discounted price in exchange for my browsing data then I'll reconsider my position.
Could AWS, Digital Ocean, Linode, <insert other low end hosts> all be trying to? Sure, I guess? Is it really central to their business model? I think that is a bit of a stretch so I'm comfortable trusting my tunneled traffic to them.