I could care less about what people learn at colleges or how someone without a degree could know more than them. It's not the knowledge that I'm after, it's the person.
Someone with a college degree has shown they can make a long term commitment, take on a large and complicated task and see it through. I know that for at least four years they have been exposed to individuals who are at the top of the industry and have learned about CS with peers who share the same interest and are now their close connections.
Although all of these might be true with an individual without a CS degree but the odds of that is so miniscule that I believe it's not worth taking a chance.
Just my opinion