Okay, I'm game: HHHnHHHHnHHHHHnnnnnnnnnHHnnnnnnHHHHH

It's a password that I postulate is more secure that the average and yet is only made of two different symbols and would've been rejected by the proposed "x amongst y" character policy.

It's a bit far fetched but not that much, you'll notice that the pattern is simply the first digits of pi, so it's fairly easy to remember. And the letters are "Hn", like hacker news.

That's my point, really. If you think you know better than the user how to pick a password, then just do it. Otherwise don't get in my way, you don't know how I generate my passwords.