Craigslist is actually a great design. Just imagine if a UX developer had their way with it. It would look like myspace.
Craigslist has a great minimalist interface. There's a lot of ways it could go wrong, and it avoids a great majority of them. That said, I don't think a lot of development has gone into actually considering their use cases and developing workflows that prefer them.
Obviously, it's still a very useful site regardless, but I would not call it a well designed site.
If a "proper designer" got hold of it, they'd ruin it.