While I also prefer a system which assumes no trust in government policy, it is still prefferable provide legal protections for the little guys whenever possible. In this case, the little guy is the vast majority of people who don't understand how the internet works.
We can't assume VPNs will always be legal for individuals with the horrible direction things are going.
I would like to add however that it would be really nice if the super-intelligent programmers on HN could come up with an open solution that is super easy to use that actually preserves the little guy's privacy. Like just a tickbox in Firefox that makes your whole PC untrackable.
Something so easy that anyone can use it, yet as secure as all the complicated technical solutions that are being presented in these comments.
I believe policy is important as a part of the solution because it is a matter of protecting the general public not just a select technically capable.
Yes, policy is hard and can be useless but I still believe it is an important goal to fight towards.
You can care about your privacy, use a VPN and use the democratic process to enact policy change. Those things need not be mutually exclusive. VPNs are only a part of the solution and incomplete, not the solution.