I hate on Peter Thiel all the time, but he's absolutely right here. MBA schools teach a form of strategic analysis that is almost purely driven by fatally flawed ex post facto reasoning. Hell, the case study model pioneered at Harvard is a case study in ex post facto reasoning. Just read their most popular business books...always looking to the past and trying to find mystical reasons why one company did well and another company didn't (while completely ignoring counterfactuals).
We shouldn't be surprised that this form of reasoning leads to really bad ideas about what the next big thing is.