Proof of its existence before down-voting would be appreciated.
Update: a quick overview of how easily sectarian beliefs could be held with support of nothing but opinions of the followers could be found a in my older comments.
Proof of its existence before down-voting would be appreciated.
Update: a quick overview of how easily sectarian beliefs could be held with support of nothing but opinions of the followers could be found a in my older comments.
The second argument is based on the first, and it is the principle that a simulation is not a valid experiment for confirming an existence of any phenomena whatsoever because it is based on dogmas created out of math and modeling, not measurable and replicated direct observations. The process of producing a highly sophisticated model is closer to a theology rather than a science, and this is the point.
With these principles it is easy to argue that this or that advanced theory could be mere a socially constructed set of beliefs which exists, like any other such social phenomenon, to benefit certain social group, say, clergymen. There is no idees fixes here. Just a bit of scepticism, philosophy of mind and sociology
It's quite tractable, and even has cool cloud chamber pictures of the trails of the objects claimed to be positrons ("Positive electrons," at the time.)
I often hear the meme that the burden of proof lies on the person making the extroardanary claim, where I assme the "extraordinary" side is chosen by the ambient culture. This might be fair, but people should stop sticking to it with such fervor - the entire point of the scientific consensus is that there is lots of evidence for it lying around. It shouldn't be hard to find a little to share.
Also, I'd like to point out that philisophical debates are the only environment in which idealism (or even social constructivism of science, for that matter) can survive! ;) If you are going to take the time to have a discussion, it will be more fruitful to educate, and share the (very interesting!) reasons behind the theories that we spend so much time studying.
You're perfectly free to doubt these claims (for whatever strange reason), but doing so would be pretty arbitrary, unless you consistently distrust the entire scientific establishment, in which case, your "bullshit detector" is badly broken because it keeps reporting too many false positives and needs to be retrained.
It is the same kind of crap as CDS or any other modern sect but in theoretical physics - the way to earn a decent living by bullshitting mere mortals.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positron_emission_tomography
> When I see a mathematical simulation (a probabilistic model) instead of a directly observed and measured natural phenomena [sic] ...
Experimental report: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positron
Picture: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/69/Po...
Also, "a ... phenomena" should be "a ... phenomenon".
That's the point - there were no direct observation.
The "proof" of existence of, say, photons is that green thing outside your window. The proof of correctness of the atomic theory you could see in the mirror. The proof of existence of antimatter are some petabytes of data from some man-made tool.
The theory behind antimatter first appeared in an equation written by P. A. M. Dirac[1]. Experimental confirmation came in 1932 in a cloud-chamber experiment conducted by C. D. Anderson[2]. Antimatter is now regularly generated and detected in many different ways, in experiments and observations that aren't based on conjecture.
> Proof of its existence before down-voting would be appreciated.
Done (replacing "proof" with "evidence", since there are no proofs in science).
Because antimatter has both strong theory and experimental validation, the burden of evidence is yours, not ours. This doesn't mean the idea of antimatter cannot be falsified by new theory and/or new evidence -- as with all science, falsifiability by empirical evidence is a requirement.
That could be a good operational definition of what is meant by the word 'sectarian'.