care to expand on this at all? it completely contradicts most everything I've heard.
saying consciousness is just a neural reaction could be right but it's by no means an understanding.
care to expand on this at all? it completely contradicts most everything I've heard.
saying consciousness is just a neural reaction could be right but it's by no means an understanding.
I think neuron function pretty well characterized. What about ions passing through membranes do we not understand?
The exact details of all neuron types and protein interactions are definitely not known but basic function is understood.
unless you can tell me exactly why and when in these processes consciousness arises, were not having the same conversation.
I like the car example. If I have a pile of car parts, they don't make a car. They have to be put in a special way in order to function. What is "car-ness" and where does it lay? In the parts, or in the configuration, or in the whole action of driving it?
the vagueness- which parts can you remove from a car before you wouldn't call it a car anymore?
the subjectivity- which parts can you remove from a car before I wouldn't call it a car anymore?
bald is another funny example of emergence (though not my own). how many hairs must one grow before they are no longer bald?
I don't really know how to condense this subject down into a HN comment and honestly it takes a lot of effort just to get the basics down. Plenty of books out there on the subject. The entire neuroscience field is a plethora of info.
We're not having the same conversation...
is there a single physical process or entity we can attribute consciousness to?
our high level understanding of consciousness is that it at some point emerges from physical processes.
this emergence is the interesting problem that we have essentially no grasp on.
we obviously have broad understanding of emergence, and pragmatic intuitive applications of it, but consciousness is not one of them.
if we understood when, where, how, or why consciousness emerges, we'd be intriguingly close to creating it.
I mean, you are making claims (roughly "we understand consciousness"). And I am just asking for some research that supports this.