If not, given that searchable archives are one of the ways Slack makes money, makes me wonder why there's not an open source way to pull the chats and archive them in a way that's cheaper and independent of Slack.
If not, given that searchable archives are one of the ways Slack makes money, makes me wonder why there's not an open source way to pull the chats and archive them in a way that's cheaper and independent of Slack.
How often do you find solutions in public archived mailing list posts when Googling problems? I imagine often. While some e-mails are more terse than others, fundamentally e-mail list posts demand a certain structure. Can you imagine having to pour through a 25-page chat log instead?
And with that, the entire idea of "search the archives before asking a question" would go to pot.
(a) is fiddly and a bit technical but has been solved-ish for ages before slack existed
(b) is fundamental though. If it's a big archive, it costs real money to provide access & search to. If you break it up, search-ability tends to suffer.
None of this is new, slack is just the latest flavor
forbid creating an off platform archive
I'm not sure that's a substantively enforceable idea.Just try and stop me?
Probably they don't care enough to enforce, but surely you see it's part of the problem that they could?
They can't stop someone from creating an archive that's inaccessible to them, if they don't know of its existense. Anyone can create an archive of something they can read and hide it, and selectively share it.
Such an agreement on curtails specific forms of automated crawling and public-facing archives.