I'm currently using a Nexus One as my primary phone, but let's please make honest comparisons.
HD video is "neat", 5MP camera on a phone is so last year though.
I'm actually more interested in the display than in the rest of the phone. It seems like a nice piece of tech. It's definitely a better sounding display than I've seen elsewhere.
Takes 480p video at maybe-20 fps. If 480p is HD, then my bad, but the iPhone 4 is doing 720p video at 30 fps.
Multitouch = innovation
Apple store = innovation
GPS = innovation
UI thought for mobiles = innovation
Apple came out first with those things. Then people catched up. This time what is the innovation? A bit more pixels on the display and the farmville client? Are you kidding me?
This is being pedantic, and doesn't really help the argument that the iphone 4 is better, but, at least one of your points is invalid.
They've all moved the slots to underneath the battery and given up the pretense of it really being removable storage.
Those features are why I picked the iPhone as my first smartphone. Other features are making me strongly consider switching to an Android phone. I know the mantra here is "design is everything, feature count is unimportant", but I think that is an oversimplification. Design (really, usability) is more important than features, but once two products are roughly as usable, well-implemented features make a big difference. Clearly, Apple thinks that these features are important, otherwise it wouldn't be choosing to showcase them.
The original iPhone had a competitive advantage
based on a "real" webkit-based browser,
visual voicemail, a large multitouch display,
on-screen keyboard with good auto-correction...etc, etc
Funny, but most of those were dismissed by naysayers when iPhone was introduced. The capabilities of Mobile Safari were mostly ignored ("I've my Opera Mini/Mobile"), multitouch ("Apple did not invent multitouch!" — and conveniently not mentioning that iPhone had capacitive multitouch), and no physical keyboard was presented as a huge flaw.I agree that it's not spouting a coffee filter and electric razor, but strongly disagree that you can step to "not innovative" "meh, useless catchup".
One part of not being measured at features/$ checklist is not being measured at -$ per lack of never seen before feature.
You've seen the Netflix announcement, now take a look at this:
http://lonelysandwich.com/post/662129889/ipad-tv
1 day ago that was posted, today we have a HD camera, iMovie and videophone announcement on a device with an upgraded screen, and talk of working with carriers for videophoning (i.e. transmitting video over the cellular networks).
This "no innovation" device might not need a USB hoover attachment to be a cornerstone piece for turning another major industry upside down in a way that others could not mostly by virtue of lots of integration, evolutionary changes and a pleasant enough UI that people wont resist.
It's about on par on quality as the HTC Evo or Droid Incredible, which is great, but not astoundingly spectacular in my opinion. And as we all know, two months from now HTC will probably be releasing some newer and better.
It's a competitive product, but in my eyes it's comparable to what's already out there, improving in the same way other products do when they're released (screen resolution, thickness, etc). It's just not worthy of getting your panties in a bunch, and certainly not worthy of migrating to it from a n Incredible, Evo, or Desire. Just not enough advantages to make it worth it.
If the fight is on software, I put my money on android: big time! Android is quicker at introducing new OS features because it's open source. I am thinking wifi tethering, customization beyond folders, web integration... and it offers a more competitive and free app market.
I'd go so far as to say that Apple never competes purely on features. They resisted putting features into the iPod (like an FM radio) for years and yet those devices still flew off the shelves. The iPhone 3GS screen is 1/4 the resolution of my now highly obsolete WinMo phone. Apple never rushes to add anything when they don't need to -- and that is not necessarily a bad thing.
I suspect the difference will be in both speed of updates and accuracy. It doesn't matter (in fact, you won't even notice) if the phone is a little "off" when pointed at the sky, but I can't see the compass+accelerometer trick providing accurate absolute positioning for a fast-paced game.