More generally, black and white thinking is often less effective than thinking in scales.
Most religious laws are absolute prohibitions or absolute mandates - no foods are mostly kosher or halal, no foods become haram or treif merely because of quantity. None of the ten commandments are quantitative or subjective. Being a frummer is burdensome and inconvenient, but it's also remarkably straightforward. Strict and absolutist behavioural rules are easy to understand and apply.
If the end goal is less meat, then, for me, the results were clear: black and white thinking was far more effective.
I've been vegetarian for 9 years.