The headline makes that claim, but the article's figures do not support the claim.
I'm not sure that it actually helps anything to cast it in the cart-before-horse way the article does.
According to the institute’s data, a two-earner couple receiving an average wage — $44,600 per spouse in 2012 dollars — and turning 65 in 2010 would have paid $722,000 into Social Security and Medicare and can be expected to take out $966,000 in benefits. So, this couple will be paid about one-third more in benefits than they paid in taxes.
Some types of families did much better than average. A couple with only one spouse working (and receiving the same average wage) would have paid in $361,000 if they turned 65 in 2010, but can expect to get back $854,000 — more than double what they paid in. In 1980, this same 65-year-old couple would have received five times more than what they paid in, while in 1960, such a couple would have ended up with 14 times what they put in.
Such findings suggest that, even allowing for inflation and investment gains, many seniors will receive much more in benefits than what they paid in.
As for how its used by retirees today and in the past, would anyone sell stock that is paying insane an unsustainable dividends? Would you blame the investor or the company? Even if its compulsory to buy?
You absolutely can opt out by choosing to exclude employers that are either mandated, or who have chosen despite not being mandated, to participate in SS. Or by choosing to live by some means other than wage-labor (if you make all your income from capital investments, you have successfully opted out of SS.) No one is coercing you to the contrary (well, except the coercion to wage-labor that affects most of the population under capitalism and which has not generally been eliminated in modern mixed economies; but even there there are some wage-labor options outside of the Social Security mandate.)
To the extent capitalism isn't slavery they absolutely are.
We can, of course, debate the extent to which capitalism is or isn't slavery.
Of course, again, you can still opt-out of Social Security within the wage-labor economy, it just narrows your choices of acceptable employment opportunities. [0]
[0] http://finance.zacks.com/groups-not-pay-social-security-syst...
You pay me $722,000 over the next 50 years, then from years 51-??? (70? 80?) I pay you the equivalent of $966,000.
I would not have to get a very high rate of return to end up better than that. Eyeballing it, the payments from the first 10 years alone, at a return of around 4% or 5%, would cover all of my outlays at the end. That's a sweet deal.
It looks like they accounted for inflation somewhat ("...in 2012 dollars"), but even returns modestly beating inflation would turn out a much bigger winner.
The bigger problem is that the govt. is not investing that money like I would if I took the bet.
I think our progressive tax system (for example) strikes a lot of people as being the same - giving some people a "free ride", but what is the alternative? The money that makes many rich people rich filters up from the millions of poor and middle class people that spend 99% of their income directly on goods and services. If you own restaurant chains, stores, factories, and/or are invested in all of those things, you benefit from the spending of the rest of the nation.
It may seem counter intuitive, or maybe its just ideologically disgusting (if you believe everyone is entirely self-made that is), but a less progressive system could ultimately harm the upper class. If the lower and middle classes don't have money to spend, our economy does not do well and given that a large amount of our wealth is tied up in financial products the last thing the rich really want is for the whole system to grind to a halt.