Hacker News Reader

Comment by AlexAltea | Hacker News Reader

> Priests and nuns work weekends, have done for centuries. Cops, food service, health care providers, prisons and the entertainment industry to name a few.

While such jobs require indeed people working on weekends, it doesn't mean that the workers themselves need to be present 7 days a week. It's possible to uniformly distribute 2 free days per week among workers and still guaranteeing 24/7 service.

> Those that lament its passing as some sort of societal shift show thier colours.

Not sure what "their colours" mean. Why should we lower our expectations to the lowest working conditions? Instead, why don't we all aspire to redistributing our working ours to ensure a fair share of free time.

View on HN

>Why should we lower our expectations to the lowest working conditions?

Because when you expect 9-5 5 days a week sat-sun off then some how the 10s of millions of us that work at all the businesses that don't keep banking hours are exceptions to the norm and because we're treated as exceptions instead of a normal, integral and enormous part (majority?) of the system: we get ignored; or treated as something that will just take care of itself if people "fix" what ever part of the system they think is the norm.

If you arent getting sat-sun off then i seriously doubt you have any stable 2day weekend. These are shift workers. By "colours" i mean that they are from a background where sat-sun weekends are a thing. Thier parents were not shift workers. They expect to have sundays off. Many, possibly most in many areas, no not have such expectations and envy those who do.

My girlfriend is a shift worker and while she doesn't always get stable 2 day weekend (she gets every other weekend off and generally Tuesday and Thursday the other week) but her schedule is reasonably stable. If you are a shift worker and your schedule isn't stable at all then that means your schedule is bad even as shift workers go

There have always been professions, such as doctors, that require some degree of 24x7 coverage but I wouldn't describe that as shift work.

In the US, probably the biggest change over the past few decades is that pretty much everything that could be closed on a Sunday was closed (with the exception of restaurants which historically closed on Monday). When I went to school and for a number of years thereafter, essentially no stores were open on a Sunday.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com