Why shouldn't a local ISP make a deal with Bing Video to stream 5K unlimited in exchange for interruption ads, while limiting youtube traffic to 1080p?
Why should Google strong-arm those ISPs (via net neutrality) into providing support for the most expensive leg of data transit between customers and youtube without offering some kind of subsidy? Why are we all crossing our fingers hoping Google offers last mile in our area rather than aspiring to start a far better last-mile ISP using cutting edge tech?
Our highways do not have "neutrality". Only certified cars and trucks capable of certain speeds who have paid registration fees and taxes are allowed on the scarce resource.
With "highway neutrality" we'd have people walking, someone on a unicycle, various antique vehicles, a bus emitting smoke, and hordes of go-carts. All this traffic would require highways to be significantly larger than they are today, possibly 20-30 lanes wide.
With highways, we know there is demand to transit between cities, so we prioritize that traffic. The traffic pays a toll to the builder of the infrastructure.
For internet, we handle it differently. We grant a monopoly to the last mile providers and then force them to charge no tolls. So they create services that allow for the most cost-savings at the expense of overall quality... This means high latency, since batching upstream is one way they save money.
A low latency internet is not compatible with net neutrality, unless a latency requirement is built into the regulation as it is with POTS.
Since most content demanded (in bytes) is video, the network characteristics to optimize video will dominate ISP buildout, and all other protocols will suffer.
If ISPs build to meet demand, and massive services like YouTube are heavily demanded, then net neutrality offers competitive protection for YouTube/Google (the Halliburton of advertising), blocking local ISPs from doing deals that would challenge YouTube's dominance.
But why would an ISP build to meet demand for other services/protocols when the bar is simply set at providing adequate YouTube streaming? There is no incentive to push for better/faster protocols and more granular, tiered pricing.
Proponents of Net Neutrality need to detail exactly what QoS settings they are calling for, so that we can all evaluate specifically how our desired use-cases will be impacted.
Low latency, rather than burst bandwidth, is by far the most important characteristic of the last mile internet, and so we should be wary of any policies that de-emphasize latency.