Well the Xerox Star was $16,000, the Mac $2,000. And the Mac did have localTalk, a super cheap 232 kbps office network that worked really well.
When the Mac was released, the Xerox team actually had a much different reaction than yours. Notice the screen shots in the PDF, every object fits in a rectangular area. The original Mac supported non-rectangular regions, making it's graphics far more advanced than the Star, despite the much lower power hardware. Xerox engineers were flabbergasted the Mac could do that.