Yes, don't use globbing to find source files! CMake doesn't record that the file list came from a glob operation, so it doesn't set up the dependency checking to handle it. (Not all targets support this sort of thing anyway. I bet GNU make does a good job of it, especially if you use gcc -MMD and pattern rules; I rather doubt Ninja supports it; Visual Studio definitely doesn't.)
With manually-specified source file lists, using the Ninja, GNU make, NMake and Visual Studio generators, I have had to re-run cmake by hand no more than a few times, each time seemingly due to a bug somewhere. (Possibly my fault... I can't remember having had to do this with my current project.) Aside from that it's good at detecting when relevant files have changed, CMakeLists.txt included, and reinvoking itself as part of the build.
CMake has plenty of horrid parts, and there's probably plenty of reasonable workflows that it doesn't support, but I have to say that I've found the day-to-day workflow perfectly satisfactory...