In the end I changed the strings that specified the problematic/missing fonts in a hex editor (I naively assumed that would do the least damage...) to a compatible font I eventually found after some digital archaeology. LibreOffice accepted these files but didn't display them correctly (as in: according to what my eyes and brain expected - "machine readable" was in a different universe at this point). I saved the hex-edited documents in whatever version of docx LibreOffice exports to. Word accepted these, displayed them as well as could be hoped, and a little bit of modern history could be saved for future generations. Not a very technical approach, I guess.
I feel the 1990's in general did a lot of damage. It's not only Word. Competing, proprietary formats together with lacking text-encodings (and in my case custom fonts messing up character tables, due to academic/linguistic needs) has caused more information loss than the decades before and after for the data I've worked with.
Suffice to say I use plain text as much as possible (markdown, latex), as text-encoding alone is hard enough.
To be clear on definitions, my understanding of "interoperability" involves the following workflow - if I open a complex document made by someone else in MS Excel or Word, change one word in it, save it (in MS format) and send it back, then I have to be sure that I haven't corrupted anything else in that document - layout nuances, styles,references, pagination, whatever. Currently it's not the case, and it makes it unusable, since I can't even verify if something looks different on my computer than it had looked in MS Office.
I mean, it's a simple test - if opening ("importing"? "converting"? technically that might be more appropriate than merely opening) a document and immediately saving it changes it somehow, it's not ok.