> Finally, it is worth noting that educators have long promoted a large number of different kinds of thinking: engineering thinking, science thinking, economics thinking, systems thinking, logical thinking, rational thinking, network thinking, ethical thinking, design thinking, critical thinking, and more.
As a former teacher, which do I prioritise? There are a set number of hours in a school day, and I still need to teach the basic facts such as:
glucose + oxygen --> carbon dioxide + water
and:
Bonjour == Hello
Why would I waste time teaching "Computational thinking" if it's unproven whether or not it only actually benefits programmers?
I feel like the article addressed that point head-on with the paragraph below. If computational thinking benefits only future computer programmers, and does not benefit anyone else, then that is a reason not to teach computational thinking to all children, isn't it?
If this isn't addressing for you whether there is a reason not to, what would a reason not to teach computational thinking need to look like for you? Would it have to do active harm before it becomes a reason not to?
"The boldest claim of all is that computational thinking enhances general cognitive skills that will transfer to other domains where they will manifest as superior problem-solving skills. Many education researchers have searched for supporting evidence but have not found any. One of the most notable studies, by Pea and Kurland in 1984, found little evidence that learning programming in Logo helped students' math or general cognitive abilities. In 1997, Koschmann weighed in with more of the same doubts and debunked a new claim that learning programming is good for children just as learning Latin once was. (There was never any evidence that learning Latin helped children improve life skills.) Mark Guzdial reviewed all the evidence available by 2015 and reaffirmed there is no evidence to support the claim."
Or, substitute for "religious" anything you dislike - "superstitious", "homeopathic", "racist", "left-wing", "right-wing". Or more fairly, as the article suggests, compare teaching "computational thinking" to teaching Latin. Clearly there is at least some reason you think "computational thinking" is worthwhile. What is it?
We cannot, after all, teach children everything. There is simply too much it is possible to learn.