hey guess what, western classical harmony that bach kind of codified, is but
one harmonic system. its accidentally super arrogant to ignore the insanely deep musical traditions that are not present in western classical music, since they have different ideas about harmony. one of the great things about music is that it has really opened my eyes to this kind of of cultural myopia. its so obviously implicit in pretentious analyses like these, even if their content is interesting and correct, that the writers believe that western music is the
real music. its trained into alot of us that that is the case. well, its not. its not superior, nor inferior. someone is going to read this and think im being an sjw, but i assure you! i once implicitly thought this way too, but i studied other music besides my first love, which was the music of bach, and its true! the musical traditions of roma people, indian classical music, american jazz, bluegrass, flamenco, romanian folk music, turkish music (just whatever is coming to me in this moment) etc etc these things are so deep, and have such rich traditions of insane dedication. so, dispose of this idea that bach's music is the only real music.
the same kind of weird cultural narcissism / racism / whatever it is happens in language, with "correct" usage of words. its the same damn thing.
and can i just add, for all the overly left brained harmonic analysers out there- it would be nice to see someone address the fact that harmony, even in the restricted western classical sense, i guess "diatonic", depends greatly on timbre and range as well. of course i didnt read this paper, and instead ranted somewhat incoherently about topics which might not even apply to the paper, but hey, i had a good time!