"the claim that something hadn't any negative impact on you because you turned to be out fine, without comparing"
I'm lumping that in under "studies" about health effects.
> In the equation, 10 = y - z, you cannot say that z is 0 without knowing y, right?
> I am saying just that.
Yes. You are. But we have good baselines for y, and the person is trying to make an argument about the entire population of zs, so while you're correct that there is uncertainty on the y, the way you went about it is only relevant to thought experiments and your later replies were very much exacerbating a fruitless discussion.
And like I added later, you can't even measure y with magic twin earths, so there was even less reason for the comment at all.
>EDIT: regarding branching timelines and butterfly effect, are you talking to yourself?
The comment you were replying to was talking about "twin earths". Your specific comment said "your version who never had shots". That's what I'm referring to with "branching timelines". Sorry for using alternate wording.
I can avoid using the phrase "butterfly effect" if you want. It's shorthand for: Once you change something, like vaccine vs. no vaccine, there is a chance that the "twin earth" or "your version who never had shots" comes out completely differently for essentially random reasons. Tiny little differences in what you experienced the day of the shot cause different outcomes later that are entirely unrelated to the shot itself.
So it's actually irrelevant whether you can test against this "your version who never had shots", because the act of performing the injection screws up the list of "random" events that happen to that other-you. And once that happens, you're basically measuring two different people. And you can measure two different people on normal earth.
So there is no y vs. z comparison, not even in the thought experiment you were replying to.