How did you compare you with your version who never had shots? Or how did any vaccination trials do it?
How did you compare you with your version who never had shots? Or how did any vaccination trials do it?
Their point is almost exactly the opposite - we know vaccinations work without requiring a 'twin Earth' that the grandparent posited. Exactly the same applies to whether e.g. cannabis is linked to cognitive decline.
I ask . "Is it logical to reach the conclusion x based on y" and people are responding as if I have said "x is not true"! and they are saying things like "whether X is true or false does not matter because Z!"
HI larious!
That studies don't have literally the same people in both groups.
Especially when the main problem with "I turned out fine, so it must be safe" is that the person is confusing anecdotes with statistics, not any deficits in rigor caused by lack of access to branching timelines.
It's no wonder people are confused about what you're actually trying to say. So you don't have to be intentionally condescending with "you should go back and read the comment again ellipsis".
Edit: Oh great you added similar language to this comment while I was replying. Cheers.
Edit 2: Even if you had branching timelines, the butterfly effect ruins your ability to know if your intervention is the actual cause of any particular outcome. Maybe one version of the participant skips a plane flight five years down the line, and that changes their health in a major way.
Go back to my first comment and tell me where I mention any kind of studies.
All I was point was at the logical fallacy in the claim that something hadn't any negative impact on you because you turned to be out fine, without comparing with a version of you without the influence of that something...
In the equation, 10 = y - z, you cannot say that z is 0 without knowing y, right?
I am saying just that.
EDIT: regarding branching timelines and butterfly effect, are you talking to yourself?
I'm lumping that in under "studies" about health effects.
> In the equation, 10 = y - z, you cannot say that z is 0 without knowing y, right?
> I am saying just that.
Yes. You are. But we have good baselines for y, and the person is trying to make an argument about the entire population of zs, so while you're correct that there is uncertainty on the y, the way you went about it is only relevant to thought experiments and your later replies were very much exacerbating a fruitless discussion.
And like I added later, you can't even measure y with magic twin earths, so there was even less reason for the comment at all.
>EDIT: regarding branching timelines and butterfly effect, are you talking to yourself?
The comment you were replying to was talking about "twin earths". Your specific comment said "your version who never had shots". That's what I'm referring to with "branching timelines". Sorry for using alternate wording.
I can avoid using the phrase "butterfly effect" if you want. It's shorthand for: Once you change something, like vaccine vs. no vaccine, there is a chance that the "twin earth" or "your version who never had shots" comes out completely differently for essentially random reasons. Tiny little differences in what you experienced the day of the shot cause different outcomes later that are entirely unrelated to the shot itself.
So it's actually irrelevant whether you can test against this "your version who never had shots", because the act of performing the injection screws up the list of "random" events that happen to that other-you. And once that happens, you're basically measuring two different people. And you can measure two different people on normal earth.
So there is no y vs. z comparison, not even in the thought experiment you were replying to.
Then the blame is on you, Not me.
> Then the blame is on you, Not me.
Okay, I think there's been some miscommunication here. Because whether we call that a study is absolutely irrelevant to either of our points. So I accept total blame for that wording? I will call it whatever you want, because it has nothing to do with my argument.
There is no need to use a time line. You can have an hypothetical machine that could extract the effects of the vaccine from your body... So you enter into this machine, and comes out as a version that never had any vaccines...There. You have got your delta.
Anyway this is not really helpful so I'll restate the part that actually matters and then peace out.
Yes you have a technically correct point, but the way you went about presenting it as "this argument is flawed" lead to people pointing out significantly more important flaws in the argument. You then sassed people instead of just letting it be or trying to refocus on what you were actually trying to contribute. Not a great strategy, all-in-all.
Like what exactly?
>Yes you have a technically correct point, but the way you went about presenting it as "this argument is flawed
if "argument is flawed" how can I present it any different...
To answer your question: How can I compare my vaccinated self to my unvaccinated self?
The answer is: I can't, because my unvaccinated self is probably dead as it would have had to have lived in a world where childhood mortality was much higher than it is now, due to various factors but especially communicable diseases.
But we were not talking about problems. The person I was replying said this
> but it can't be a complete picture vs their never-smoked potential.
So I am talking about the potential (meaning various capabilities IQ, Social behaviour, Emotional stability (withing the bound of normalcy) etc. I mean, things that are not usually recognized as problems..).
How can you compare the potential of a version of you who never had vaccines with a version of you who had a given set of vaccines. This is particularly relevant with vaccines because you don't have a version of you before having vaccines, since these are usually administrated at a very young age..
For example, I think everyone knows about the 2015-2016 Zika virus out-break and what experts believe to be a link to devastating child birth defects. This has clearly become a high priority vaccine candidate... and, we believe we already have one.
It's just that, despite the devastating effects, medical professionals/scientists aren't going to go willy-nilly releasing it to the public without a comprehensive study (ideally multiple of them), for example, the following study which is expected to complete in 2019.
https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/phase-2-zika-v...
> You compare populations. Did a group who got the vaccine have more problems than an otherwise identical group that didn't? This requires careful study design and statistical analysis, of course.
These are called identical twin studies, they're inherently limited in capacity and are not an appropriate means of studying vaccines. Vaccines are inherently something widely distributed to the public. Vaccines do have adverse effects on some people, all publicly released vaccines have publicly available figures on the likelihood of adverse effects in a percentage of the population. If the percentage is too high or the types of effects are too severe then the vaccine is not released to the public - this is common sense.
For example I was seemingly affected by a Whooping Cough (Pertussis) vaccine I was administered as a baby. After receiving part of the vaccine (it was administered in doses at the time) I became quite ill and doctors advised against administering the rest of the vaccine. So for many years I was not vaccinated against Whooping Cough but received the rest of my vaccinations without issue - again, should be common sense.
I'm a perfectly healthy adult now and have actually since received a newer/different a Whooping Cough vaccine (I don't believe they still administer the old one), as well as several other vaccinations.
I'm perfectly content with the fact a vaccine may have almost killed me, it's certainly better than the alternative of Whooping Cough running rampant killing more than the 50,000 people it already kills each year.
But with pants, I guess you never had to wonder "Is wearing pants safe".
Again. That was not the question. But I see you have answered the actual question also, agreeing with my point. So we're cool..
So, does vaccination make more healthy people, at a population level, than not vaccinating? That's the question that matters, because every action (or inaction) has risks. The evidence is abundant that yes, vaccination has helped us reach closer to our potential. Diseases like polio might even be entirely eliminated, in which case we're trading a few adverse reactions today for a nigh infinite number of saved lives in the future (if future generations don't have to even be vaccinated, it's pure benefit with no cost)
There is admittedly a weird philosophical issue, whereby a vaccine does juggle around probabilities: you're trading 1000 people getting sick with measles (say) for 10 people getting sick from the vaccine. But they're (probably) different people. Were the people who got sick harmed? Sure, but if they hadn't gotten the vaccine, they might have been harmed by the disease. It's impossible to to know for certain. But it's what happens at the population level that counts.
I'm not an anti-vaccer for the record.
The studies vs experiments problem is larger in social sciences than medicine.
Most drugs are studied using clinical trials, which contain control groups. Not perfect experiment, but close to it.
There are plenty of examples studies and trials published in scientific journals with erroneous conclusions. With a purwly scientific experiment that would be impossible (at least for the experimental outcome to disagree with nature).