It shouldn't have been possible to warn seven times, the autonomous car's job is to protect society from bad drivers.
It shouldn't have been possible to warn seven times, the autonomous car's job is to protect society from bad drivers.
>"Following the May 2016 accident, Tesla announced a new update in September to help keep drivers from using autopilot if they don't respond to in-vehicle safety warnings."
From that article in turn:
>"From version 8, if three audio warnings are dismissed within an hour, Autopilot will be disabled until the car is parked. "Autopilot accidents far more likely for expert users; they get very comfortable with it and repeatedly ignore the car's warnings," Musk said, describing the way these drivers dismiss alerts as "a reflex action" and adding that Tesla's data shows that some users dismiss three warnings a minute.
At least as of that version last September Tesla was apparently still allowing longer hands-off periods at speed then others in the industry, with the above-45-mph limits being 1 minute of free travel and 3 minutes when following another vehicle, and I don't have the knowledge to make an opinion on whether that's a reasonable length or not at their current level of development. Regardless, this accident from last May did result in changes and apparently wouldn't be possible with the current firmware, or at least not in the same exact manner.
Also possible: The car warns the driver, he puts his hands on the wheel long enough to shut it up, car warns the driver again. It's akin to blindly clicking OK when annoying, useless error messages pop up. Do Teslas have lots of false warnings, training people to ignore them?
In LA - some people are so stupid as to not get off to the shoulder after a collision and also walk around on the freeway, exchanging information, etc.
So while there is danger involved, traffic can adjust to a car with hazards on even if it's in a freeway lane. The Tesla's should be able to detect the shoulder and if not, come to a gradual stop on the right lane.
Slowing the vehicle may increase the risk of a collision from behind, but that is balanced by the increased risk of not having a driver at the wheel.
I agree that other cars should be notified if a car is unattended too, just in case they get to an area where the system cannot respond.
I'm pretty sure it's also designed to pull over and stop if it doesn't get feedback ensuring someone is paying adequate attention.
But maybe the parameters or functionality was different at the time of this crash.
I think autopilot is a great marketing concept but a terrible and inaccurate description of the technology.
I had a lot of distrust for the system (and was hovering the brake) since I hadn't used it before. I had to get used to the controls, the UI, the steering wheel prompts, etc.
It works quite well but around the city you'll get to a lot of places where it can't make decisions. One that I recall was an elevated intersection. So the car is going up a slope while it's losing the lines on the road. To the system, it's kind of like a ramp leading to a jump off a cliff, haha.
I'm sure these tougher scenarios get ironed out after getting safe feedback from user takeover. But what if the system makes decisions based on other user's actions and then something changes in the road but the sensors can't react?
I'm used to driving with one hand on the wheel and one hand on the stick. The car being electric doesn't make me want to all of a sudden change all my habits.
I was referring to the claim that it checks for 10/2 positioning of hands.
the autonomous car's job is to protect society from bad
drivers.
Interestingly, this is the same argument a class action lawsuit against Tesla is making. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/04/tesla-says-there... The suit claims that the Model S and Model X are
defectively designed and that Tesla did not "develop and
implement computer algorithms that would eliminate the
danger of full throttle acceleration into fixed objects"
even if caused by human error.
Right now a Tesla vehicle will let you override the computer, even if that means driving through a wall. https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Tesla... Depending on how the lawsuit turns out, that may change.