If everything is manufactured overseas or by robots, retail is largely locked up the a handful of giant corporations who can bankrupt competitors, in many places the former middle class spends all their disposable income on housing and can't afford new services, and the 1% largely don't spend their money. And on top of it, the utopia promised by diversity is actual splitting societies, right when we most need cooperation and unity.
To me this is start to look like an near unsolvable problem.
(The implication is that war and violence has a very high cost and so alternativas should be considered)
Fine. Then leave. But then you don't get to participate in the market.
This isn't that hard a problem. If you make the money in the US, you get taxed in the US. If you leave the US, you don't get to take the money made in the US with you.
The problem is the lack of political will to close those loopholes that allow otherwise to occur.
Even if they do leave, someone still owns it.
Most wealth (not GDP) is indeed in real assets... and these assets are obviously owned. They're typically owned by companies, not by individuals (directly), which is why in the response I gave below I mention foreign shareholders. If somehow you mange to exclude them you have dozens of other loopholes and contractual mechanisms to contend with, the most obvious being leasing by the property company of a real asset owned by a bank, wherein the lessee in turn sublets the asset out.
If you get past that you have to deal with the fact that in a very real sense these assets constitute the bulk of wealth because their prices are high, and that if you make it extremely difficult (or undesirable) to own them the price will plunge as current owners try to sell off their assets and get cash to take out, and nobody with the relevant criteria to own them has enough funds to buy them. That in turn would wipe trillions off wealth, hundreds of billions off GDP, and send the banking system into a new systemic cardiac arrest demanding of bailouts in because the assets underlying their outstanding loans no longer cover the risk they're exposed to.
Now there is not much of a middle class remaining. Many bills are due, and this is the end of the line — both for the 1% and everybody else.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_in_the_United_States#We...
Robots change all this. For the first time in history, we are nearing a system where the rich don't need the poor. Whether it's producing food and other goods or even fighting their wars, the rich will soon be able to rely solely on automation to feed, clothe and protect them. Automation could create a system that doesn't have to collapse, no matter how top heavy it becomes.
Every first world nation can afford to unconditionally give basic food, basic shelter and basic entertainment to every one of their (not global, though) poor people without asking work or anything else in return. Implementing something like this would be a major political and organizational problem, but economics-wise there's nothing preventing it; the industries that cover those needs for everyone take up a significant but still small percentage of the total GDP.
Education and basic healthcare is already provided by many societies (USA is a bit of an exception, as it is in most things). Those parts doesn't even need any major changes or restructuring to provide for everyone, I was quite literal when stating food, shelter and entertainment as the core needs of unemployed/unemployable that would need such a change.
Apart from the fact where you're killing people for no reason, it's not very capitalist at all.
The cultural and economic future of the nation is being legislated by the current victor. It will be interesting to see how this plays out.
This is a powerful phrase that hopefully finds common usage. Perhaps we'd all have less contempt towards opposing views if we are reminded that violence occurs when contempt levels get too high.
[1] http://takimag.com/article/the_cold_civil_war_grinds_on_john...
http://williamgibsonblog.blogspot.com.au/2006_01_01_archive....
(Via a friend on Mastodon -- I very much liked your usage of this term.)
At the same time, it's the rural and urban electorates being played off one another.
That's a long con.
https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/6i3lj3/the_urb...
https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/6i2h0e/ahm_jon...
So the people that really control things would have you think. In reality, it is being legislated by the same people that have been in control for decades now. Who that might exactly be I do not know.
Just like the US housing bubble & crash, it is like a train wreck in slow motion that after the impact, everyone will be claiming no one could have seen coming.
The economic repercussions of increased local manufacturing (you don't outsource weapons manufacturing to your enemies) combined with increased demand for workforce are pretty well understood.
Which also kind of explains why right-wingers tend to be disproportionally warmongers. War's good for business, after all.
Still the level of web-developer who has little more skill than using Excel for pivot tables is also the web developer who can do little more than make static websites, which is plenty enough to be a webdev in 95 or even in 2005, but unlikely to be enough in 2017. I have just made different orders from two different websites today (cables and clothing) and both websites made decent usage of javascript, search, etc.
Besides that, many factories had thousands of employees; even a modest store may have ten - but watchapp needed just 50 programmers to be sold for a double digit billion dollar sum.
EDIT: almost forgot the corporate controlled mass media to tell the population everything is mostly fine and nothing can be done to improve anything.
Thats why I was asking about nk.
More people can be web developers until the labor market balances out supply and demand and web developers make median income.
Pretty sure i can command value over either.
Knowledge work is not ditch digging. A body is not a body.
It won't help. About half of new college graduates are doing jobs that don't require a college education. Those are the ones heavily in debt, with a negative return on investment for college.
http://www.byui.edu/online/degrees-and-programs
Reviewing the degree requirements and courses, and having studied CS at BYU myself, I'm betting the quality is very high. In fact I wish, as a web developer currently, that I could have taken some of these courses instead of courses like advanced algorithms; though fascinating, I'll bet I would have enjoyed a basic security course or a vector graphics course much more.
Politicians can talk about 'jobs' all they want, but the real key is education. Because jobs of the future will ALL require some highly technical skill.
The fact that high school graduation rates went from 6% at the beginning of the century to almost 80% at the end, means that humans are capable of learning a wide variety subjects ..inherent ability is overrated.
EVEN if it were the case that college is a filtering mechanism my point still stands because tuition free education increases the availablity of education to those with the ability. And we won't waste our countries intellectual capital. This improves the individuals lives and the economy as a whole
Education is absolutely an "enrichment mechanism". With the exception of upper level math or particle physics is attainable by anyone.
This is not the case. If my thesis is correct, which I think it is, you could replace college for the vast majority of people with 1 standardized test for thousands of times less cost. Don't you think its odd that the college boom started just after IQ tests for employment became illegal?
When IQ tests were outlawed for use in employment, with the exception of the military and universities (a hilarious irony), it became uneconomical for employers who needed well-above-average people to train their own employees, as they could not filter for intelligence first. Before Griggs vs Duke Power it was common for an uneducated person to score well on an IQ test, get promoted, learn on the job and work their way up to the top. Now that same person is forced to go to college, waste thousands of dollars and years of wages to do the same thing, giving a cut to the professors and the administrators (most of whom have conveniently propounded IQ denialism until just recently when the science has become so blatant that it is embarrassing to do so). This system vastly decreases the probability of someone improving their lot.
Maybe it would be nice if everyone were equally intelligent.
Maybe it would be nice if everyone were equally tall.
But this isn't the case, and if you base policy on the supposition you get the waste and rent seeking that is emblematic of the education system at all levels.
Measuring height is an objective biological measurement. IQ is a measure of a state of consciousness with so many different confounding factors.
This is a Nature vs Nurture question and you're going 100% all in on the Nature side of the argument....some sort of inherent genetic IQ predisposition.
Saying one has a permanant IQ is equivalent to saying mexicans inherently like to steal hubcabs.
When it comes to measures of IQ and other states of consciousness environment plays a massive role.
Google "labeling theory" and "Motivation theory".
IQ tests are proven to have so many counfounding factors that they're not taken seriously.
For example: 1> Groups exposed to abstract reasoning problems during school or prep courses do way better on IQ tests...
2> IQ is also shown to increase as people get older....
3>Not to mention going to university is shown to INCREASE one's score on IQ tests....
So how accurate of a test is that?
The reason it's outlawed is because it's essentially stereotyping.
It's a bullshit oversimplified view of how the brain works, and factually incorrect and Nazi-ish.
We can have an oversimplified filtering system, a single test that determines peoples futures.......or we can put people in an environment like university where education and learning is encouraged...and see if they meet their genetic potential.
I think the second way is less insane.
Hence the entire nature vs nurture debate.
Consciouness is too complex to be summed up by any single test and any person remotely knowledgable about the subject will agree with me. But it's been interesting talking with you.
Like centuries of social science research haven't thought of that?
Like you had a suddenly original idea that tens of thousands of people who have dedicated their lives to this field, gotten M.Ds and PhD's, hadn't thought of?
And if twin studies were conclusive wouldn't it have answered the debate of nature vs nurture that we're having, once and for all?
You're trying to summarize human consciousness, which is extremely unpredictable, and no one understand fully... into one test...It's extremely dumb and pretty much everyone but you agrees...and for good reasons...
Maybe your educational environment is lacking..
It is the case that social science post 1950s largely failed to address the idea that cognitive ability is heritable (and the heritability of most mental traits). I agree, the situation is absurd and embarrassing for these fields. But this is what happened.
I would like to say again, please do read the book. There were times when I was outraged by a position, to the point where I insult a person who is writing in good faith (as you have just done); this is usually a sign that I am reasoning backwards and am defending a position out of emotional attachment rather than trying to understand what is true. I would suggest this may be happening to you now.
One thing to keep in mind is just because something is true doesn't make it good. You can preserve your moral outrage even as your descriptive beliefs change.
Apprenticeship would work particularly well in computer science.
There also community colleges and other lower technical tracks that people could do for the less motivated.
The point is the option is still available which benefits,the individual, our economy and the human race. It's like a no brainer win win situation for everyone.
People get a longer education => Jobs get more selective about education and require longer studies => People have to get a longer education to get a job => Jobs get even more selective => etc...
Cheaper education will create more educated people, unfortunately that doesn't create new job prospects.
The difference is, with everyone educated, now you have a highly knowledgeable populace who are capable of solving harder problems, starting business to solve these problems, etc. I would rather have 1000 people working on Cancer research than at the DMV pushing paper or laying brick. Things machines can do.
We would have a net improvement in people's lives and the human race.
It's like a win win for everyone.