But if ad revenue is what you want, be advertiser friendly. There's nothing unreasonable about that.
It's easy to say, "Just stop advertising," but producing valuable content is expensive. Advertiser-funded outlets are at a tremendous financial advantage, and that translates directly into higher viewership. Consequently, we get the vast majority of our news, information, and opinions from advertiser-funded institutions.
Furthermore, the majority of advertising dollars come from clients who share similar attributes with each other (rich, corporate, favoring the status quo, etc.), so their perspectives and agendas tend to align.
The result is that contradictory perspectives are pushed to the sidelines, no matter how correct, logical, popular, or morally superior they may be. The fact that people aren't allowed to discuss war on YouTube is something we should all be concerned about. It's de facto propaganda.
This applies to more traditional media, too, not just the internet. There are all sorts of topics that advertisers won't "allow" even the mainstream media to dwell on for too long.
Some videos to illustrate:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tn46t8NksX0 - h3h3 "We're at an Important Crossroad"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=03dTJ4nXkXw - 2veritasium "Why YouTube Used to Prefer Quality"
In particular, consider the thought experiment presented in the second video: If YouTube's algorithm solely promoted car videos, then car videos would be all that are uploaded to YouTube. The algorithm is the content.
Even though it happens to align with what you like right now, the bias should be concerning.
That's assuming that people only upload videos on Youtube to monetize them. Given that uploading videos is basically free I'm sure there'd be no shortage of non-car videos. Actually if I recall correctly youtube didn't have any monetization for many years when it started?
What you'd probably lose is high production value original content, although I suspect that many of those content producers might still break even if they have other ways to monetize their content.
If YouTube doesn't make it available to those advertisers who would accept it, someone else should. That is, if there is (a) enough inventory and (b) enough advertisers (and if not it's an immaterial issue)
Keep in mind that what's material to Google is significantly larger than what may be material for a small company. Google is focused on finding their next $10B in revenue.
For example, based on some channels I subscribe to:
Boundary Break has 178,000 subscribers, and makes $844 a month on Patreon. A Start Show has 500,000 subscribers, making $429 a month on Patreon. Source Gaming makes $80 a month with 4000 subscribers and Top Hat Gaming Man $120 a month with about 7000.
They all make good content, but they certainly wouldn't make enough to live on through Patreon alone if they were required to.
And even that's more money than a lot of creators make from it. I know good YouTube creators whose Patreon accounts bring them either literally nothing or between $5 and $15 a month.
In other words, Patreon basically never makes as much money for a creator as YouTube ads and monetisation does, and even the best cases (people with millions of fans) make at best a lower middle class income from it.
It's just not viable for most YouTubers.
It's not dangerous, no longer requires expensive equipment, rarely involves a commute. I think most people would rather play or talk about games than flip burgers.
The problem with creative work is that the fruits of your labour are nonlinear. A single dumb video made in the spirit of the moment might get a million views, while one that you toiled over for days receives only a fraction of that. Of course doing nothing gets you nothing, but using hours-worked as a yardstick probably won't work.
You can try and migitate this uncertainly. By looking at trends, seeing what videos are popular, making content about whatever the new big thing is at the moment and by putting a lot of effort into your writing or production values.
But at the end of the day, it's at least much luck as skill and time that determines your success. I've seen people who are terrible video creators get hundreds of thousands or millions of subscribers simply by being in the right place at the right time. For instance, the Irate Gamer got big not because he was a particularly talented individual, but because he was a family friendly Angry Video Game Nerd alternative in a time when the nerd was getting super popular and YouTube wanted to present others like him.
Others got popular because a big news site posted about their work, or a creator with millions of fans like PewDiePie mentioned them on social media or their channel ended up in a related channels box on a large channel or because a bunch of people on Reddit came across them and thought their work was good.
And it can easily go wrong for successful or skilled people too. Doug Walker thought Demo Reel was going to be the next big thing, but it failed miserably to the point he had to bring back the Nostalgia Critic to keep his business going. I know a pro game designer with decades of experience in the industry who made a series about his speciality on YouTube... and squeaks by with about 300 subscribers. There have been more amazing looking websites and apps than I can name which tanked hard while their worse looking, worse functioning competitors took off.
Content creation (and perhaps creation in general) is a volatile, very hard to predict thing that has made fools out of experts and millionaires out of fools at an almost equal rate.
There's a lot of work that goes into any decent show and it climbs exponentially with quality.
That takes a lot of time to set up, especially as each game needs to be treated as its own thing due to how they're coded. Probably dozens of hours with the community on Discord figuring how the camera format works, then even more using it to explore the hell out of the game to find interesting stuff before even making the video.
Or in the case of Slopes Game Room/Guru Larry/Top Hat Gaming Man, looking into game series and games either from decades past (which have very little documentation online) or aspects of games people didn't know about. It's only thanks to them that stuff like Drivergate (a scandal where a video game magazine publisher gave artificially inflated reviews to a broken game to get the reviews out early) came to the surface or got added to Wikipedia in the first place.
A lot of time goes into these videos, it's just a lot more of it likely goes to research and journalism than editing.
It also helps that Delos has a great crew and they do rotate in a group of good looking women who don't have problems with getting topless or naked and it not have it be sexual.
My favorite channel thegreatwar seems to pull in 16k/month on patreon.com
But, yes the web needs some form of micro payment system to replace ads.
The compromise would be to have a separate pool you get assigned to where advertisers can choose to use your videos. That way a gun manufacturer can choose to advertise on a channel that advocates gun violence (an unsavoury example, I know).
This is doubly weird because YouTube has always had (and still has) one of the most atrociously toxic comments sections on the Internet.
Comments aren't monetised content, however; which makes them, in some sense, rather more honest and genuine. We'd see something very different if people were posting comments to be monetised in some way or another (although I can't see how that could ever happen.)
Heck, it should be clear that advertisers don't choose what videos they advertise on, so why should they even care what their ads run on? I really don't buy the complaint that 'GM is sponsoring terrorism' when an ad of theirs is ran on an ISIS video.
There's gotta be more to those decisions beyond just number of eyeballs and purchasing power.