I also don’t understand what the alternative is: just take people at their word they are great programmers?
We've had great success giving candidates a week to design and implement a small application from end to end. It really let's you see everything all at once. Can they design? Good comments? Good data structure selection?
It's the best of all worlds. The candidate has time to really show off their ability, you'll get a much more holistic view of their skills and it puts them equal footing with the interviewer because they've had a lot time to think about the problem. We found that whiteboard coding questions tend to favor "geek jocks" that are really just good test takers.