I don't know about the Droid or RIM phones, but here is a video of a Nokia E71 exhibiting the same signal drop behavior when being held: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=amPG52DVQuk
In the anandtech iPhone review he has it compete with a Nexus One and can measure a significant (though smaller) signal drop with the Nexus One using the same grip. I imagine you could reproduce the problem with every phone of similar dimensions.