Of course if your BTC is not real, but is held by an exchange such as Coinbase, how you get your BCC isn't at all clear.
Of course if your BTC is not real, but is held by an exchange such as Coinbase, how you get your BCC isn't at all clear.
So what Coinbase has is similar to a call option on BCC.
Please stop saying this. Read your own grandparent comment:
> There is no "conversion", it is free money for all BTC holders. Everyone who owned BTC, now owns BTC+BCC.
It isn't possible to spend BTC on the BCC blockchain, because coins spent on the BCC blockchain are BCC by definition. Once you've spent your BCC on the BCC blockchain, you still have your BTC on the BTC blockchain; that's what a fork means.
I would have expected the two forks to coordinate sufficiently to make sure double spending is not possible. But I see how this would have been extremely difficult if not impossible without one of these two rival camps agreeing to be the opt-in network while the other one remains the default.
Your BTC should still be "real", but the exchange holds the keys instead of you. Your point stands about it being unclear how you would access your BCC. If you aren't allowed access to your BCC, there's nothing preventing exchanges from dumping the BCC for cash as far as I can tell from a purely technical standpoint (IANAL).
Normally it doesn't matter as long as the exchange is capable of sending you back the coins when you claim them but in case of a fork they'd have to buy two coins instead.
I'm aware that exchanges in the past have behaved very irresponsibly, but I'm hoping that Coinbase is the exception here as a well known US-based company.
Because technically, all you have is the promise of the exchange to transfer you the right amount of BTC out of your account whenever you request them, or the same market value in another (supported) crypto/fiat currency. This is not only a pinky-swear promise but one protected by some laws and contracts.
But it is very questionable to me if there is (or should be) any obligation for any exchange to pay you any amount of BCC that magically appeared overnight.
"Customer deposits are not sent anywhere. Unlike other financial institutions, we do not lend out customer funds. 100% of your funds are securely stored."
https://support.coinbase.com/customer/portal/articles/667213...