If these guys have the proven ability to modify user records, could you use that as a defense in court? What's to say I didn't create an account, never downloaded anything, and someone else modified my account to say I did?
IANAL.
The bottom line is that suing individual file-sharers is an inane idea to begin with. The RIAA/MPAA are using this only as a shock & awe tactic. The rolling back of the file sharing tide will not come from the direct prosecution of every file-sharer. Their hope is that many people will become fearful of prosecution, thus resulting in a reduction of piracy.
In a civil court, all they have to do is prove that you are guilty more likely than you are innocent.