>
We're well into ad hominemI'm not saying it is wrong because Taibbi wrote it. It's wrong because he got basic facts about interbank lending wrong, i.e. that it exists. I'm then passing along my observation that, whenever I've fact checked Taibbi, his facts have tended to be wrong.
> Matt Levine...said the exact same thing
Taibbi said there is no interbank lending. Libor is totally made up. Levine said that there is less interbank lending and so some of the numbers had to be made up some of the time. He concludes the paragraph you quote with this sentence:
"[Libor] was all more or less good enough as a casual system for resetting the rates on a few billion dollars worth of syndicated loans, but it was not accurate down to the hundredth of a basis point as a foundation for the financial system, or as the source for pricing hundreds of trillions of dollars of derivatives."
That's important context. Libor was a good enough number for a market where precision didn't matter (syndicated loans). It proceeded to be used, and abused, improperly. It's not a totally made up number like Taibbi makes it out to be. It's a totally inappropriately-used number.
TL; DR You'll walk away better informed about almost any financial topic reading Levine over Taibbi.