>Every day, a half-dozen Rotten Tomatoes staffers scour the web to find every review of every movie, collecting from major news outlets and well-known critics. They read each review and determine whether it is mostly positive or mostly negative.
>About half of the critics who appear on Rotten Tomatoes — often the more obscure set — submit their reviews, along with the ratings, to the site themselves. As reviews are indexed, Rotten Tomatoes calculates the score. http://www.timescolonist.com/entertainment/movies/rotten-tom...
The notion they cherry picked reviews comes from the more than standard deviation away from Audience and Top Critic Reviews.
As far as your last statement, it does not appear you actually understand how a review is determined to be Fresh or Not for the Tomatometer