I won't defend FP24, but FP16 is a widely supported IEEE standard.
For the most part when you have hardware that supports one of the binary standards say FP32 you'll have a compliance sheet, more often than not it will not be 100% compliant for example NVIDIA GPUs were not IEEE 754 compliant when Tesla came out, 2nd Generation Tesla cards were FMA compliant, div and sqrt operations were not IEEE 754 compliant until Fermi.
So the GP was correct, back in the old DX9 days when AMD went with FP24 and NVIDIA with FP16/32 both implementations were proprietary, and this is still the case, they just often offer a 754 compliant mode. You can disable 754 compliance to run faster (sometimes considerably so) e.g. in CUDA you can use the NVCC flag --use_fast_math to do so.