https://techcrunch.com/2017/08/29/google-retires-the-tango-b...
https://techcrunch.com/2017/08/29/google-retires-the-tango-b...
Apple's purchase of MetaIO and its focus on just SLAM is really the right way to go. Maybe improve it a bit via specialized hardware when available (progressive enhancement in a way), but at least start with SLAM.
Google didn't have to be behind on AR at this point in time if they had ditched the focus on Tango hardware and instead focused on SLAM.
But that is water under the bridge, Google is now on the right track after being forced to do so by Apple.
Including depth sensing HW was the right solution, but Google doesn't have its own popular smartphone as a forcing function. I predict eventually Apple will include a depth camera, or they'll use dual-cameras to try and synthesize it, and once that happens, then all Android manufacturers will follow suite.
If AR is to be useful, it's got to be a lot better at tracking and drift, at making sense of the world, of supporting occlusion and mapping.
I always thought Kinect Tango and other HW-dependent solutions were a fad, and SW-only on ubiquitous cheap sensors is the right solution. SW keeps getting cheaper, faster than HW does.
I predict that, even if Apple (re)starts the custom-HW fad, within 10 years we'll see devices with good-enough camera-plus-SW AR outnumber specalized-HW AR devices by at least 10:1, and it'll only get more extreme over time.
(Mind you, that prediction requires that we continue to get performance-per-watt-per-dollar improving; i.e. it assumes that Moore's law finds a way to outlive current processor fabrication technologies.)
> If AR is to be useful, it's got to be a lot better at tracking and drift, at making sense of the world, of supporting occlusion and mapping.
That's for sure.
The Tango model of using extra hardware is probably much better, but seems further ahead. The software model works today on existing devices and lets people see how this is useful. Once you have that convincing people it's with the money to have the hardware added to the phone becomes easier.
Given how many Android phones are lower cost than the flagship was Tango ever going to be very popular? Apple could have forced the issue (like Lightning or the headphone jack) but people could always switch Android OEMs to get something cheaper if they don't see the value.
I have a feeling the end game of this is going to be that Tango-like devices are used for mapping the world, and ARKit like libraries consume the geometry.
That is, not everyone has to own a device with depth sensing. For example, if Streetview-like services using LIDAR, or if self driving cars with LIDAR, map point clouds of most outside areas, and merchants and vendors map into areas with specialized Tango-like HW, then most of the benefits of depth sensing AR can be had for people without depth sensors.
It would be a mostly static 3D map of the world, not frequently updated, but probably good enough to enable a large number of apps.
The kind of people that buy flagship Android phones would probably either see the value or be price insensitive enough not to switch over it.
OTOH, “works ok now” is often more important than “works better later”, so getting something out that will work with today's flagships has value even if Tango would be practical down the road.
When Pokémon Go came out I was very disappointed to find it's much hyped 'AR' was really just rendering ok top of a live camera image with no tracking at all.
The demo of the ARKit version from WWDC is what I had been expecting.
Not really. If you're someone who values updates, you're kinda stuck paying for a certain tier of device.
I'm just thinking about your average person who goes into at Best Buy or cell phone store and wants a new android phone. Given to similar phones, one with the extra hardware and the other cheaper, if they don't see the point they'll probably go with the cheaper one.
If they got to use software only AR stuff on their previous phone that may change that decision.
I could be wrong, but I was under the impression they already leverage the dual cameras on the Plus phones.